These shoes feel and look very high quality. I wear a size 8 in US women's and got the medium size, and my toes feel a tiny bit squished, but not so much that they're uncomfortable.

The squeaking is cute, but if you don't want them to make noise there's a little hole on the heel where the air comes in/out, and I imagine you could block it to make it stop.

My only concern is that I feel like I have to be a little careful with claws to avoid them getting messed up. These are more for decorative wear then practical wear.